A Comprehensive Comparison of Top Koi Pond Supply Brands: A Certified Aquascape Contractor's Perspective

Building a tranquil and aesthetically pleasing koi pond is a cherished dream for many homeowners and garden enthusiasts. With an abundance of koi pond supplies brands flooding the market, choosing the right products can be overwhelming. We’ve been in the business long enough to understand the significance of selecting reliable and top-quality supplies for creating stunning water features that enhance the natural beauty of any landscape.

In this blog post, we will delve into a comprehensive comparison of popular koi pond supplies brands, emphasizing their key features, quality, and effectiveness from our professional perspective. By examining these brands through the lens of a niche water feature company, we hope to guide homeowners and fellow contractors alike in making informed decisions when embarking on their koi pond projects.

koi pond installers using aquascape koi pond supplies installing outdoor water features

Aquascape Inc.

Aquascape Inc.,  founded by Greg Wittstock the Pond Guy, stands as one of the industry pioneers, recognized for its premium-quality products. Their wide range of koi pond supplies includes pumps, filters, water treatments, and fish food. With an emphasis on sustainability, Aquascape Inc. offers environmentally friendly solutions that promote healthy pond ecosystems. Their expertise in pond design and equipment has earned them a spot as a go-to brand for both professionals and DIY enthusiasts. 

As Certified Aquascape Contractors, we choose to use Aquascape pondsupplies because of their reputation in customer service, products, and brand. While we know not every company will have the products necessary for every particular custom job, Aquascape does do an amazing job of finding ways to tailor their products to fit the majority of construction styles. 

Positive Aspects:

  • Premium-quality products with a wide range of options.
  • Emphasis on sustainability and environmentally friendly solutions.
  • Expertise in pond design and equipment, making them a go-to brand for professionals.

Negative Aspects:

  • Some customers have reported higher price points compared to other brands.
  • Limited availability of certain specialized products in some regions, which may inconvenience customers outside major markets. (We definitely fall into this category and strive to provide Aquascape products readily available and deliverable to our clients.)


Pondmaster has established itself as a dependable brand with a focus on innovation and performance. Their pumps and filters are known for their efficiency and durability, catering to koi pond owners who seek long-lasting solutions. 

Positive Aspects:

  • Dependable and efficient pumps and filters, known for their longevity.
  • Commitment to innovation and continuous improvement in product performance.

Negative Aspects:

  • Occasional customer complaints about customer service response times.
  • Availability of spare parts for older models can be challenging, making repairs and replacements more difficult.


TetraPond is a household name in the pond supply industry, renowned for its broad range of products tailored to meet the needs of every pond owner. From food and water treatments to pumps and accessories, TetraPond offers a comprehensive selection. Their user-friendly products are especially beneficial for beginners, making pond maintenance a breeze.

Positive Aspects:

  • A household name with a comprehensive selection of products for pond owners.
  • User-friendly products suitable for beginners and DIY enthusiasts.

Negative Aspects:

  • Some customers have reported inconsistent product quality across different batches.
  • Limited variety in specialized pond equipment, which may not fully meet the needs of advanced pond enthusiasts.

Alpine Corporation

Alpine Corporation is recognized for its aesthetically pleasing and functional pond décor. From pond fountains to lighting and statuary, Alpine offers a wide range of options to add a touch of elegance to any water feature.

Positive Aspects:

  • Aesthetically pleasing pond décor, adding elegance to water features.
  • Wide range of options, including pond fountains, lighting, and statuary.

Negative Aspects:

  • Some customers have reported durability issues with certain pond décor items.
  • Limited availability of specific products in certain regions, leading to challenges in finding desired items.


Microbe-Lift is a brand that focuses on natural pond care through beneficial bacteria and enzymes. Their water treatments aid in maintaining water clarity, reducing organic waste, and promoting a balanced ecosystem.

Positive Aspects:

  • Natural pond care through beneficial bacteria and enzymes, promoting balanced ecosystems.
  • Water treatments aiding in maintaining water clarity and reducing organic waste.

Negative Aspects:

  • Longer timeframes for noticeable results compared to chemical-based pond treatments.
  • Some customers may find the microbial approach less intuitive to use than traditional chemical treatments.


Oase-Atlantic is a renowned brand that has established itself as a leader in the koi pond supplies industry. They offer a comprehensive range of pond equipment, making them a top choice for koi pond enthusiasts.  

Positive Aspects:

  • Reputable brand known for its innovative and high-quality pond equipment and supplies.
  • Offer a wide range of products, including pumps, filters, skimmers, and pond lighting, providing comprehensive solutions for koi pond enthusiasts.

Negative Aspects:

  • Some customers have reported that certain Oase-Atlantic products may have a higher upfront cost compared to competitors.
  • Availability of Oase-Atlantic products in some regions may be limited, making it challenging for customers outside major markets to access their offerings promptly.


Savio is renowned for its durable and reliable pond equipment. However, their products could be relatively more expensive, and finding replacement parts for older models may be challenging.

Positive Aspects:

  • Offer a variety of products, including skimmers, filters, waterfall weirs, and UV clarifiers, providing a comprehensive selection for koi pond projects.
  • designed with a focus on efficiency, ensuring effective water management and maintenance.

Negative Aspects:

  • The range of specialized products offered by Savio might be limited compared to other brands, which could pose challenges for those with unique pond requirements.
  • Obtaining replacement parts for older Savio models may be challenging, affecting the ease of repairs and maintenance for long-time users.


EasyPro Pond Products offer a diverse range of high-quality supplies at competitive prices. While they cater to a wide range of customers, some users have noted that certain products may have a shorter lifespan compared to premium koi pond supplies brands.

Positive Aspects:

  • Includes both budget-friendly options for beginners and professional-grade equipment for experienced pond builders.
  • Diverse range of products, including aeration systems, pond liners, water treatments, and fish food, catering to various aspects of pond management

Negative Aspects:

  • While EasyPro Pond Products provides a good selection of basic pond supplies, they may not offer the same level of specialized products or cutting-edge technology as some premium brands.
  • Some customers have reported that certain EasyPro products may have a shorter lifespan compared to higher-end brands, potentially leading to more frequent replacements.

Koi Pond Supplies Company Opinion:

As Certified Aquascape Contractors, our experience has taught us that selecting the right koi pond supplies is essential to the success of any water feature project. The brands mentioned above have demonstrated a commitment to quality, innovation, and sustainability, making them top contenders in the industry. 

While these brands are well-known and respected, our experience has led us to make careful considerations when selecting koi pond supplies for installation.

One critical factor we assess is the ease of installation. As professionals, we prioritize efficient and seamless installations to ensure a smooth process for our clients. Some brands in the search for cutting-edge technology might also come with complex installation procedures that can be time-consuming and challenging to execute correctly. We strive to work with products that strike the right balance between performance and ease of setup, allowing us to deliver exceptional results efficiently.

Another significant aspect we take into account is the maintenance requirements of the products. While certain brands may offer top-of-the-line equipment, they might also demand meticulous and frequent maintenance, which could burden pond owners with additional upkeep responsibilities. We aim to recommend products that strike a balance between high performance and ease of maintenance, enabling our clients to enjoy their ponds without unnecessary hassle.

Customer service and warranty issues are also vital considerations in our decision-making process. As professionals who prioritize our clients’ satisfaction, we value prompt and reliable customer support. Unfortunately, some brands may fall short in providing adequate assistance when customers encounter warranty-related issues or have questions about their products. We believe in working with brands that stand behind their products and offer exceptional customer service to ensure our clients’ peace of mind.

Ultimately, the functionality of the products is of paramount importance to us. Our reputation as Certified Aquascape Contractors relies on delivering outstanding water features that thrive and bring joy to our clients. 

Based on our extensive experience, we proudly stand behind the Aquascape products we install, which have consistently met our high standards for ease of installation, maintenance, customer service, and functionality. We are dedicated to providing our clients with the best pond supply options available, resulting in water features that are both breathtaking and sustainable for years to come.

beautiful pink flowers against a gorgeous koi pond with custom fountain showcases talent of koi pond construction builders and outdoor water feature installation

The Basics of Koi Pond Construction: Creating a Serene Oasis with the Aquascape Method

Welcome to River Rock Water Gardens! If you’re considering building a koi pond or having a professional like us build one, you’ve come to the right place. In this comprehensive guide, we will delve into the basics of koi pond construction, with a special focus on the Aquascape Method. Whether you’re a seasoned pond enthusiast or a beginner in the world of water gardening, this article will provide you with the essential knowledge you need to create a breathtaking koi pond in your own backyard.

Read More »
koi pond repair services Bentonville, Oklahoma by river rock water gardens koi fish and water feature inspiration

Upgrade Your Outdoor Space with a Professional Pond Installation